If GitHub Was Like Berlin…

Much open source research assumes that all open source projects are alike and that if you take enough of them, you can claim generalizability for your conclusions. GitHub is the main source of such mischief, because of its size and availability.

If GitHub was like Berlin, and projects on GitHub were like the people of Berlin, then treating all projects the same is like saying that a person from Mitte is like a person from Kreuzberg is like a person from Spandau.

You can slice and dice as much as you want by how tall people are (say, lines of code), how wide they are (community size), or how old they are. It doesn’t tell you anything about their soul (community governance).

It is community governance that leads if not outright determines behavior. While people have suggested models for this, they are not used for classifying projects nor are they used as independent variables in analyses.

Try telling a Berliner that people from different neighborhoods have the same needs, have the same goals, are all the same…

Posted on

Comments

  1. Shane Curcuru Avatar

    Um, some projects still use Subversion/Bitbucket/Mercurial/etc. so the original premise of evaluating just Github projects is flawed to start with. 😎

    1. Dirk Riehle Avatar

      Yes! But this has never stopped anyone from wordsmithing his or her claims of generality 🙂

  2. Mike Linksvayer Avatar
    Mike Linksvayer
    1. Dirk Riehle Avatar
      Dirk Riehle

      Thanks for the pointer. Yes indeed!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Share the Joy

Share on LinkedIn

Share by email

Share on Twitter / X

Share on WhatsApp

Featured Startups

QDAcity makes qualitative research and qualitative data analysis fun and easy.
EDITIVE makes inter- and intra-company document collaboration more effective.

Featured Projects

Making free and open data easy, safe, and reliable to use
Bringing business intelligence to engineering management
Making open source in products easy, safe, and fun to use